Why are Trade Barriers Necessary for Protecting Employment?

On this page, we focus on why trade barriers are necessary for protecting employment.

Trade barriers refer to government-imposed restrictions on the exchange of goods and services between countries. These can include tariffs, quotas, embargoes, and other regulations. While trade barriers might seem like a hindrance to global commerce, they play an essential role in protecting employment within a nation. This article explores why trade barriers are necessary for protecting jobs, providing explanations, referencing theories, and citing examples, particularly in the South African context.

Why are Trade Barriers Necessary for Protecting Employment?

Trade barriers are necessary for protecting employment because they help shield domestic industries from foreign competition. By implementing measures such as tariffs, quotas, and regulations, a country can level the playing field for its local businesses, allowing them to grow and thrive. This, in turn, creates and sustains jobs within the nation. Theories like Import Substitution Industrialisation (ISI) and the Infant Industry Argument support this approach, advocating for the replacement of foreign imports with domestic products and the protection of emerging industries until they can compete on their own.

Examples like the South African poultry industry, where tariffs on imported chicken protected local jobs, illustrate the practical application of trade barriers for employment protection. While these barriers must be balanced with the potential drawbacks of protectionism, they remain a vital tool for safeguarding domestic employment and promoting economic self-reliance.

Explanation of Trade Barriers

Trade barriers are tools that governments use to regulate international trade. They might include:

  1. Tariffs: Taxes on imported goods.
  2. Quotas: Limits on the number or value of certain goods that can be imported.
  3. Regulations and Standards: Rules that imported goods must meet, often related to quality, safety, or environmental standards.

Theories Supporting the Use of Trade Barriers for Employment Protection

Several economic theories support the use of trade barriers as a means of protecting domestic employment.

1. Import Substitution Industrialisation (ISI) Theory

ISI is a trade policy that advocates for replacing foreign imports with domestic products. By doing so, it aims to foster local industries and create jobs.

2. Infant Industry Argument

This theory posits that new and emerging industries in a country may need protection from foreign competition until they become strong enough to compete on their own. Protection, in this case, can help create and sustain local jobs.

Examples of Trade Barriers Protecting Employment

Trade barriers can have a profound impact on employment in various sectors of the economy. Here are examples, including one from South Africa:

1. South African Poultry Industry

South Africa implemented tariffs on imported chicken to protect its domestic poultry industry. This move helped safeguard local jobs by making imported chicken more expensive and encouraging consumers to buy locally-produced chicken.

2. American Steel Industry

The United States imposed tariffs on steel imports to protect its domestic steel industry, aiming to save jobs in a sector threatened by foreign competition.

The Balancing Act: Protectionism vs. Free Trade

While trade barriers can protect employment, there’s a need to balance protectionism and free trade. Over-reliance on trade barriers can lead to:

  1. Higher Consumer Prices: Protectionism often leads to higher prices for goods, as competition is reduced.
  2. Potential Trade Wars: If one country imposes barriers, others might retaliate, leading to a cycle that could harm international trade relationships.

Conclusion: Trade Barriers as a Tool for Employment Protection

Trade barriers serve as essential tools for protecting domestic employment, particularly in developing or vulnerable industries. Theories like ISI and the Infant Industry Argument provide a framework for understanding why these barriers are implemented. Real-world examples, such as the protection of the poultry industry in South Africa, demonstrate the practical applications of these policies.

However, a nuanced approach is necessary to balance the benefits of employment protection with potential drawbacks like higher consumer prices and strained international relationships. In the South African context, and indeed globally, trade barriers must be carefully calibrated to serve the national interest while maintaining the broader benefits of international trade. By understanding and judiciously employing trade barriers, nations can foster domestic industries and safeguard jobs while engaging in the global economic community.

Looking for something specific?


Related Posts